well said

Jeremiah of the Granite Studio’s take on the Shanxi slave case can be found here.

I haven’t written much on the case, nothing more than a couple of links, because I can’t figure out how. Yeah, maybe part of it is that old compassion fatigue, but really, how can you feel compassion fatigue in such a case?

I’ll quote Jeremiah’s last paragraph:

“Slavery in any form is an abomination. The enslavement of Africans in the early part of our history is one of the United States’ darkest hours. The act of taking slaves is cruel and inhumane and serves as proof that evil exists in the hearts of men. But it has nothing to do with “underdevelopment.” It is about greed, and corruption, and a system that consistently fails to protect the weakest and most vulnerable members of society. The exposure and total abolition of forced labor should matter more to any responsible government than comparatively petty issues such as “national image” or “face.””

I lived in Taiyuan for a year and heard many horrible, heartbreaking stories of the sheer poverty to be found only a few kilometres from my school. And the industrial slum I was living in was bad enough, but these stories were worse. But I never heard anything so horrific as this slave labour case.

And of course, despite the poverty I could see around me and the even worse stories I was constantly hearing, there were still plenty of black Audis with tinted windows cruising the streets.

But on the other hand, this comes as absolutely no surprise. The sheer number of stories I’ve read of all kinds of human trafficking, abuses of authority, inhumanity…..

I’m going to stop now. I don’t know where this is going.

No Comments

and so finally it has happened…

China is number one.

No Comments

amazing

I’m amazed at just how frustrating this Typepad block is turning out to be. I didn’t realise just how many Typepad blogs I read.

Of course, I really should be using my time more productively…..

Update: blogs.com is a part of typepad, right? Well, this site is accessible. So it would seem it’s typepad.com addresses and typepad blogs (but maybe not all) with their own addresses that are blocked, but blogs.com is still open.

2 Comments

compassion fatigue

Lonnie explains the drive behind the China Dream Blog.

The post also includes a call for help:

“David and I only want one thing from you, and it’s not money nor pats on the back (we haven’t done anything yet). The only thing we want is for you to social network our requests for people’s dreams. Tell your friends to send us their dreams. Link to us, favorite us on Technorati, and tell others to do the same. Give us a few minutes of your time and a little space on your blog (which we know are valuable), and we’ll do our best to reflect credit on your generosity.”

So send him links, favourite him on Technorati. Apart from the reasons he gives in his post, he’s also doing this to raise money for two good causes.

I also like how he starts this post:

“One of the lines I repeatedly quote from Waiting for Godot is “Habit is a great deadener.â€? The more we see poverty, death, disability, illness, and systemic dysfunction, the more we become desensitized to it. The more we add charitable acts to the bottom of our to-do list, the more we deaden our reflexes to react to immediate human crises.”

And he includes a great cartoon on the same subject.

But I know I feel the compassion fatigue he refers to. When the news is little more than a constant bombardment of images of suffering, destruction, death, oppression, disaster, eventually my brain just has to perform some kind of emergency shut down before it explodes. I’m just one small English teacher in Beijing. What can I do?

Or to quote one of my favourite songs:

In the paper today tales of war and of waste
But you turn right over to the t.v. page

But, like many Crowded House songs, although it has a note of melancholy to it, there’s also a kind of hope:

Hey now, hey now
Dont dream its over
Hey now, hey now
When the world comes in
They come, they come
To build a wall between us
We know they wont win

So I guess, at the risk of getting all sappy, one of the promises I see in the China Dream Blog is its potential to help break down walls.

Oh, and I categorise this as ’tilting at windmills’ because that’s how I feel putting up posts like this. I think Lonnie’s project has a much better chance of success, though.

No Comments

fax machines, bureaucracy, and noise outside my window

Ah well, the usual bureaucracy involved in renewing residence permits, transferring foreign expert certificates, and generally doing anything more complicated than breathing, is causing its usual round of headaches. I wouldn’t have noticed had the office fax machine hadn’t thrown a paddy (where in hell did that phrase come from?! I’d be surprised if it has any anti-Irish connotations considering how often my of-Irish-descent mother used it when I was a child, and yet I wouldn’t be surprised, because it was my of-Irish-descent mother who used it most). No big deal, though, after a bit of struggle, we convinced the fax machine to cooperate.

About the only thing I like about this part of town is that, despite the unusually large transient population, there is a real community here. I can hear it in the warmer months when the windows are open and various community activities are happening outside. Things as simple as brothers and sisters (yes, they exist in “one child” China) squabbling, husbands and wives arguing, or various song and dance sessions or gatherings of people just hanging out. It’s the kind of noise I want to hear in the background, the kind of noise that makes a place seem liveable, perhaps even home-like.

I remember the three months we lived in Songyu Xili, not far from BeiGongDa, when we had a primary school outside the back window. Every Monday morning at 8 am, if I wasn’t up already (which was most likely, seeing as that was one of the periods I had no steady employment) I’d be woken up by the National Anthem being blasted out the PA system of the primary school as they started their school assembly. When that noise died down, it was replaced with the clackclackclack of the Eternal Majiang Games played constantly by the laotaitai and a few laotou oustide our side window (our apartment was at the end of the block, giving us windows on three sides). Sure, we were only there for the summer, and the advent of cooler weather would’ve changed the community sounds, and I was really glad for the space and air and light that Tongzhou offered when we moved out there, but still, I have really fond memories of living down there, even if it was only for three months. It felt so much like the kind of place you could settle in to.

I mean, it only took me a day or two to find my beer-, water-, and other staples- suppliers, although I should admit that we were both already reasonably familiar with the area, considering that when we met, I was living at Shuanglong Xiaoqu, just around the corner, and we had many reasons to be passing through that area (the local branch of Jinbaiwan/金百万 being one of the bigger reasons- and damn! that was just 20 metres from our apartment there! What the hell were we thinking when we left?!), but still, it was a really easy place to settle in to.

Can you tell? I’m really, really looking forward to moving back down to that part of Beijing. Even if we’ll be closer to BeiGongDa, we’ll still be very much in the Songyu Li realm of existence, a half hour walk from Panjiayuan (a pleasant half hour walk, I should emphasize), and generally in an area both of us know and love.

Anyway, the point I was going to make was that it’s that feeling of actually living in a real community, even if, by virtue of your skin colour, native language or nationality you’ll never be accepted as a real member of the community, that can really make or break your China experience. Far too many of us foreigners in China find ourselves segregated into either foreign teachers’ accomodation (which is usually completely separate from anybody else’s accomodation; if not, then closer to students’ dorms than regular folks’ community) or those “expat-friendly” ridiculously expensive places common around Beijing’s CBD. Judging from my experience, living in an ordinary, average Beijing residential area both makes you feel much more at home and brings the experience so much closer to home than anything else. And I suspect the same would hold true for the rest of the country.

No Comments

worth our salt?

So I sent lzh this article about average salaries or wages or whatever (I could never remember the difference, except that ‘salary’ is allegedly derived from the Latin word for ‘salt’ (sal? sel?) and it came to mean “money you earn” because Roman soldiers were often paid in salt, or some such bullshit) and her response was words to the effect of:

But that isn’t so different from what we earn here!

So basically, even with me as just another foreign teacher and her having just started her career, we’re probably better off in Beijing than in NZ. Or in other words, here in Beijing it’s not so much us not being worth our salt, as our salt not being worth us, and in New Zealand, it’d be even worse.

And on the subject of news from the NZ Herald (meaning: yet another tangent):

Alinghi has decided to shit all over the culture of one of the world’s strongest yachting nations (and that ‘strongest yachting nation’ bit isn’t an idle boast. NZ has always been near the top, if not at the top, of the sport). Sure, it’s only the America’s Cup, which is really just a bunch of rich bastards wasting money, but still, the least they could do is try to come up with a legitimate excuse…. Oh wait, America’s cup, which has a history of fighting things out in the courts and other inappropriate places for all sorts of bullshit reasons as much as actually sailing. I say that when Team NZ wins, they change the rules to make it a series of waka races around the Hauraki Gulf.

And why the hell does Switzerland even try to pretend it can have a yachting team, anyway?

 

 

No Comments

an accusation

Got this message over MSN from lzh:

“æ??醒大家,以å?Ž éº¦å½“åŠ³ã€?肯德基 一定è¦?è®°å¾—è¦?å?‘票 麦当劳ã€?肯德基æ¯?年在中国因为我们ä¸? 习惯è¦?å?‘票的原因而掠走将近20亿元的税收 把这æ?¡ä¿¡æ?¯å®Œ (ä¸? 加任何修改å¤?制)å?‘2个群的奖励200Qå¸? å?‘3个群的奖励一个太阳300个Qå¸?.以次类推.
(此活动由中国税务局赞助)”

My really bad translation:

“Remind everybody, from no on at McDonalds and KFC you must remember to get a receipt. McDonalds and KFC every year in China, because we’re not in the habit of asking for receipts, are plundering close to 2,000,000,000 yuan in tax revenue. Send this complete message (don’t add any revisions or copies)…”

Now, I’m sorry, but that bit about the rewards is way over my head. I’ve got no idea what it’s talking about. I know “Qå¸?” is one of those virtual currencies. But I can’t figure out what “一个太阳300个Qå¸?” is supposed to mean. I guess the statement “I know “Qå¸?” is one of those virtual currencies” is a pretty big giveaway that I don’t bother moving in circles where I would learn what such things as “一个太阳300个Qå¸?” would mean. But such things don’t interest me, and so I’m sitting here thinking “One sun and 300 Q dollars? What?” And I can’t figure out what “群” is supposed to refer to. Group? Is this a defined number of people?

Anyway, translation queries aside:

Interesting, though, that little note at the end: “此活动由中国税务局赞助/This activity is supported by the China Administration of Taxation”. My dictionary, which is a little out of date, gives the name of the organisation as “国家税务局/State Administration of Taxation”. Has the name changed from ‘State’ to ‘China’? If not, is this an indication that the message does not, in fact, have official support from the tax department?

And why are McDonalds and KFC being targeted? Because they’re nice, big, fat, juicy foreign targets? The rather emotive language (“plundering”, indeed!) would suggest so.

Now, it’s my understanding that McDonalds operates on a franchise basis. That means that your friendly, local, tax-dodging McDonalds is not actually foreign-owned. The person dodging the taxes is Chinese.  And if the remedy is as simple as demanding receipts, then that suggests to me that the problem is, in fact, local.

Lastly: Doesn’t every small business do this? Why pick on two big foreign brands (especially when the people doing the tax dodging are most likely Chinese) when it’s common knowledge that pretty much every restaurant, privately-owned store, taxi driver….. whoever, is probably doing the same thing- paying taxes only according to the receipts issued. So we should all demand receipts everywhere.

Anyway, I have no idea how much truth there is to this accusation, but there’s a lot in it that has alarm bells ringing, and they’re not the “Run and smash up the local McDonalds” alarm bells. This smells too much like the work of ill-informed, ignorant, self-styled patriots. You know, the kind that insist that there’s some giant foreign conspiracy to hold China down and abuse her people (like the Shanxi slave case, right?).

Anyway, I can think of plenty of good reasons to boycott McDonalds and KFC and others of their ilk, and I can’t say I’ll be shedding any tears if Chinese franchise holders suddenly find themselves having to report more income and pay more tax. But I would’ve appreciated this message lzh passed on a lot more if it took a more rational, realistic approach.

2 Comments

Yizhuang revisited

I hate having to go out to Yizhuang every Monday evening. It’s not just the awkward timing of it, nor is it just the mediocre students. It’s Yizhuang as a whole.

Now I’d be the first to admit that my experience of Yizhuang is extremely limited. Limited to a few rooms in one building, the views from that building, and the views from the car window as we arrive and leave. Certainly not enough to speak with any authority on the subject. But enough, perhaps, to get an impression.

And that impression is of overwhelming emptiness. I don’t know why. On the way in and back out everything is built up, there’s traffic, the roads, although some of them are undergoing repairs, have obviously been there a while. But still the place feels empty to me.

Maybe it’s because most of the buildings I see are commercial or industrial. Or maybe because it’s the view from the conference room where I give the lesson. Or maybe it’s the lack of pedestrian or cycle traffic.

The conference room is on the 13th floor Floor A. Small tangent on the subject of pandering to superstition: The building has a fourth floor, but floors 13 and 14 have been renamed A and B. No, I don’t understand that decision, either, and asking the students about it got only confused nonsense.

Right, back to that view. Looking out the conference room windows on the 13th floor Floor A, the streets are laid out in a regular grid pattern, only broken by a few odd roads here and there. To the left is a construction site. Immediately below is the car park, and in front of that is an empty field. In one corner of the field is a small yard filled with construction…. stuff. Materials, equipment, just stuff. To the right of the carpark is a similar yard, but this one with a few shacks in it, some like the kitset shantytown that is nearly finished just outside our gate here, others an older style, made out of what seems to be the same asbestos shingles Roubaozi and I helped put on the sheep pen back at May Day. Beyond that is a reasonably nice looking housing development. But the next couple of blocks, directly ahead and diagonally ahead to the left and right (in front of the construction site and the housing development) is all empty fields. Beyond the fields, in all directions, are the usual commercial and industrial buildings, construction sites, and a few housing developments. Most of the construction sites are for more commercial and industrial buildings.

So maybe the emptiness has something to do with the apparent lack of any real city life. There are a few residential areas, but not much, and I haven’t seen much in the way of the usual city life-level commerce, like restaurants and supermarkets and all the myriad little stores, to support those areas. A little, but not a hell of a lot. And what about children? I arrive in Yizhuang about five in the evening, and yet I never see the hordes of school children you’d expect to see about that time.

Anyway, so far as I know I only have one more trip to Yizhuang next Monday and then I’m free. Can’t say I’ll be sorry to see the back of the place.

No Comments

slaves

I hope you’ve all been following the case of the slave-labour in illegal brick kilns in Shanxi. Personally, I have neither the stomach nor the heart to tackle this story myself. There are others out there better placed to be dealing with this one, and I’ll leave it up to them. One of those, of course, is ESWN, and he has another great post on the subject here.

No Comments

yahoo, again

And this time it wasn’t China Uselesscom fucking up my internet connection. It was Yahoo. Again. For the last month or so access to Yahoo, or at least to anything beyond the front page, has been dodgy at best. And Yahoo has developed this most irritating habit of pretty much hijacking all the minuscule amount of bandwidth China Uselesscom provides, meaning it pretty much buggers up everything and makes getting any website to open, even Chinese government sites, damn near impossible. Not only that, but the problems persists for a few minutes after any window or tab with anything Yahoo in it is closed.

So I don’t know what’s going on with Yahoo, but of late it’s been making China Uselesscom look good and reliable.

rant完了

No Comments